Pricing and clients Recorded on a real call

Why would an agency turn down a monthly retainer?

From an intro call with a business owner about his marketing, 10 March 2025.

By Manan Mehta · 20 November 2026 · 4 min read

Unscripted. Clipped from a real call. Only my side is shown.43 seconds
The short answer

Because a retainer that doesn't get results just becomes a bill every month. I've seen it: the relationship goes bad, nothing changes, and the client never comes back or sends anyone else. In a crowded market, word of mouth is the only real marketing left. So I scope a project first, and only add ongoing work if it's needed.

I turn down monthly retainers at the start because a retainer that doesn't get results just becomes a bill every month. The relationship goes bad, nothing changes for the client, and they never come back or send anyone else. In a crowded market, word of mouth is the only real marketing left. So I scope a project first, and only add ongoing work if it's needed.

Near the end of an intro call, a business coach asked me how the commercials would work. I told him it depends from client to client, and that I would put together a proposal for him. But I wasn't going to go on a retainer with him. Not at the start, anyway.

Why don't I lead with a retainer?

I've spent years in this industry. Long enough to know that putting people on monthly retainers that don't get results, and just sending a bill every month, never helps me in the long term.

Here's what happens. The relationship goes bad. You don't create any real change for them. And then that person never comes back to you. Nor do they send other people your way.

That last part matters more than it might seem. In today's crowded market, for people like us who do marketing for others, word of mouth is the only form of real marketing left. Everything else now gets counted as spam.

That's what I believe, and that's how I run my business.

What should come first, if not monthly content?

Of course we can do some really good content for a client. A hundred other things can be done too. But what I want to figure out first is a few things that will be impactful. Things that will get results.

All of that other work costs money. And if the client's base isn't there digitally, if the funnels aren't in place, the content has nowhere to go. I could create an amazing video about him as a business coach. But if that video doesn't lead somewhere he can actually convert people, what was the point?

So the base comes first. Once things start rolling, then we can create amazing social media content and go into all of those other things.

What does the project actually look like?

I told him I would take four or five days. I wouldn't rush it. I would go through his website, through his work and his social media in detail, and build a LinkedIn strategy for reaching the business owners he wants to work with. I would only send him something once I was confident about where I could actually come in. Maybe ten things. Let's do those, start there, and then we see.

I put it to him as a project, not a retainer. An overall digital upgrade and a funnel creation system. Something with a clear start and a clear finish, where you can see what changed.

To explain what I mean by a funnel, I showed him my own. My agency targets ten core industries. I build my personal brand on LinkedIn, and on Instagram I show what we've done and for whom. From there, people land on a page made for their industry, with case studies of clients we've worked with in that industry. Then they book a call. When they book, they share their website and social media, so I can see they know what they're doing before we speak. After the call, we send a proposal.

Case studies are a big part of it. Not always a public link. Sometimes a private link you send to someone in a DM. With business owners, that's what I've seen work best. They want to see where you started, what you worked on and what you built.

The point is a system that keeps running on its own until your attention is actually needed. Otherwise you end up on pointless calls with people who aren't at that stage yet. That wastes everybody's time and just frustrates you.

Does every business need the same marketing?

No. He wasn't a restaurant. He wasn't a big brand that can say, fine, let's invest in social media content every month. His work is more of a one-on-one game. He needs ten, twenty clients. If we get him those, our job is done. He doesn't need a thousand clients coming in.

So the strategy has to be different.

Then, only if he needs it, an ongoing piece on top. Sending out emailers to his clients, for example. Or creating two videos a month of him speaking about what he does. But that comes after the system is in place, not instead of it.

So I'd rather take a few days, do the thinking properly, and fix the right ten things first.

“For people like us, word of mouth is the only form of real marketing left.”

Said on the call, 10 March 2025
Take this into your AI

Open this article in your AI assistant and ask how it applies to your business.

Read more of this on Google

Add mananmehta.com as a preferred source and Google will show my posts higher in Top Stories and AI Mode for you.

Add as a preferred source on Google
Manan Mehta
Written by Manan Mehta

I run MarketinCrew, a marketing agency of around sixty people across Mumbai, Lyon, Paris and Toronto, and AI Crew, where we set up AI and marketing systems for businesses. I work with founders as a Virtual CMO, teach Search Engine Marketing and Social Ads at YNOV Campus in Lyon, and host The Marketin Podcast. Before all of that I co-founded American Joint, a restaurant in Mumbai that grew to three outlets.

If you're paying for marketing every month and can't point to what changed, it's worth a second look. My team at AI Crew will audit your setup and tell you honestly where to start.

Get your audit withaicrew.com